I had no idea what this film was about till I chanced on an article in WSJ today.
BOMBAY, India — In the fantasy world of Indian film, Shilpa Shetty is a reigning princess, a lissome 29-year-old with a talent for twirling across Alpine meadows with muscle-bound suitors in tow. Serious drama? Well, it is Bollywood, after all.
But Ms. Shetty’s latest movie is a far cry from the song-and-dance-filled romances that define the Bollywood genre. Trading her filmy saris for sensible office attire, Ms. Shetty plays an up-and-coming ad-agency executive who becomes infected with HIV, loses her job as a result and then fights to regain her dignity — and paycheck — in a conservative society where fear and ignorance of the virus are still pervasive.
If the storyline of “Phir Milenge” — or “We’ll Meet Again” — sounds familiar, that is because the film borrows its central plot device from “Philadelphia,” the 1993 courtroom drama in which Tom Hanks plays an HIV-infected lawyer who files a wrongful-dismissal suit after he is fired by his firm.
The Indian film represents a milestone of sorts. By all accounts, the mostly (but not entirely) songless “Phir Milenge,” which opened across India Friday, is the first mainstream Bollywood offering that deals directly with HIV and the stigma surrounding the virus as major themes. In that regard, the film shows how Indian popular culture is belatedly starting to come to terms with the virus, which has infected an estimated four million to six million people.
“It was not like the usual run-of-the-mill commercial film where you have a hundred dancers,” said Ms. Shetty, who co-stars in the film with Salman Khan and Abhishek Bachchan, two of India’s hottest male heartthrobs. “That, in a way, was a welcome change.”
Public-health specialists welcome the movie. In an interview last year, Richard Feachem, the head of the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria, expressed concern that HIV was “not yet on the national radar screen the way it needs to be” in India, in part because the country hadn’t yet experienced what he termed “the ‘Philadelphia’ effect.”
In that interview, Mr. Feachem said he had had “a number of discussions with the Bollywood community about the idea that India is ready for a blockbuster film where HIV and the tragedy of HIV are worked into the story.”
Revathy Menon, the veteran actress who directed the film, said she wasn’t part of those discussions and emphasized that she was eager for her movie to succeed as commercial entertainment, rather than as a lengthy public-service ad. “There is a stigma toward my film itself,” she said. “The press is saying it’s an AIDS film. If a main character in a film has cancer, you don’t call it a cancer film.”
But Ms. Menon, who has long been associated with AIDS-prevention efforts in her home state of Tamil Nadu, acknowledged that she also approached the project with a social purpose. “Truthfully speaking, I just thought this was a cause that needed to be talked about,” she said.
“Phir Milenge” is part of a broader trend in Bollywood, whose traditional, formulaic approach — “seven fights, 10 songs, four kisses,” in the words of Taran Adarsh, the editor of the industry publication Trade Guide — is finding less favor with Indian audiences in the face of growing competition from abroad.
“Normally, Bollywood is known for escapist cinema — realism has never worked,” Mr. Adarsh said. But “with cable and satellite coming in, we have access to the best content from across the globe.” As a consequence, he said, “I think the Indian audience is slowly opening up to a lot of things which were earlier considered taboo.”
HIV is a particularly ticklish subject in this conservative and deeply religious country, where arranged marriage is still the norm. Although international experts have praised AIDS-prevention efforts in several of India’s hardest-hit states, they say the stigma surrounding the disease has greatly complicated efforts to contain the virus, which, in India, is spread primarily through heterosexual intercourse.
Kenneth Wind-Andersen, who coordinates U.N. AIDS programs in India, says condom use in parts of northern India had declined slightly in the past several years. He attributed the drop to reluctance by the former government, led by the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party, to promote condom use in national AIDS-prevention campaigns.
“When Bollywood, one of the world’s largest film industries with massive audiences, produces a film about AIDS, everyone has to sit up and take notice,” Peter Piot, the executive director of UNAIDS, said in a statement from Geneva.
Ms. Menon said the subject matter required delicate negotiations with the producers of “Phir Milenge,” who initially balked at the idea that Ms. Shetty’s character, Tamanna, acquire the virus during a one-night stand with Rohit, an old high-school flame played by Mr. Khan. But Ms. Menon said she rejected a proposal that Tamanna become infected by means of a tainted blood transfusion.
“In India, 80% or more is sexually transmitted,” she said. “I think we’ve just had enough of this hiding behind the blanket of one woman, one man, which is not there anymore in society. It’s high time we faced the truth.”
Ms. Menon also had a hard time finding a bankable male star to play the role of Rohit, who acquires HIV from a promiscuous American girlfriend and ultimately succumbs to AIDS. After Ms. Menon was rejected by several prominent actors, Mr. Khan — known for his action-adventure roles and bulging biceps — “dropped from heaven” and agreed to take the part, Ms. Menon said. Mr. Khan, Mr. Shetty and Mr. Bachchan, who plays the lawyer who argues Tamanna’s discrimination suit, acted in the film for a fraction of their normal fees, Ms. Menon said.
“I felt this was the best opportunity as an entertainer to give back to society,” Ms. Shetty said. “Sometimes you do films for the money, sometimes for the job satisfaction. I did this for the latter.” Besides, added the veteran of more than 30 Indian films, “It gave me the opportunity to reinvent myself.”
Well, the film must be watched, I guess… Calling Shilpa Shetty a *veteran* made me smile…:-)
On a more serious note, “In India, 80% or more is sexually transmitted,”… Is that true? What about infected needles? Infected mothers?
rileen says:
Well, Shilpa Shetty’s been around for 11 years now – yes, that’s how long it’s been since Baazigar was released!
Planning to see the movie?
August 31, 2004 — 6:28 am
Lakshmi says:
Would like to…
August 31, 2004 — 6:34 am
hariputtar says:
very punny.
phir milenge,
fillyphilly ?August 31, 2004 — 7:02 am
Lakshmi says:
Re: very punny.
*sheepish*
The ‘Philadelphia’ connection?
August 31, 2004 — 7:05 am
splitpeasoup says:
A few years ago, I remember reading that HIV transmission in Bombay and TN was mainly prostitution-related whereas in the North-East it is related to shared needles among drug users.
Since it is a very fast-spreading disease, I have no idea whether the above information still holds true.
About seeing the movie, I am a little conflicted. I am intrigued by the subject matter, but Salman Khan is a big turn-off.
August 31, 2004 — 7:30 am
Lakshmi says:
I’d read that bit of info too. A few years back…
I agree…on the Salman Khan bit.
August 31, 2004 — 7:35 am
harish_an says:
you are right
seems like these stats are true . 85% actually is sexually transmitted
i recall there is a high incidence of aids among street workers and truckers…mostly spread back into family by the men:)and also due to the onus of the prevention of pregnancy on the woman.
but the problem here is that these stats are not off a very dependable sample given the stigma to get a test done or to go to a doctor if a symptom is noticed…or because many times the aids related death is not correctly diagnosed and attributed to other diseases that come due to the immuno deficiency
August 31, 2004 — 7:25 pm
lalunadiosa says:
It’s WSJ right? They are used to actors in Hollywood who act in one film every year or every other year….so for them someone who has acted in 30 films is a veteran….for eg: Tom Cruise has been around for more than 20 years now but he has acted in just 20 or so films (not including the cameos and stuff)….
And it sounds like a film worth watching (a) for the unusual (if not original) storyline and (b) ‘cos Revathy is directing it (even though she acted in movies like extremely forgettable Love, she always came across as a strong-willed woman and I’ve always admired that)
August 31, 2004 — 9:09 am
99kanitas says:
it’s a great movie! watch out for revathy’s cameo 🙂
buzz abt. shilpa shetty & national award.
abt. infected mothers – they’ve started testing pregnant women (in Bombay atleast – definitely was there 1998-9) before they deliver (and i think they also issue a certificate), so if they are infected, then they’d have to abort.
August 31, 2004 — 9:35 pm
Lakshmi says:
That sounds good.
September 1, 2004 — 7:08 am
roopa1978 says:
I wanted to see the movie over the weekend.But everyone else wanted to see Fida, so ended upseeing Shahid Khan’s muscles instead.
Phir Milenge should be interesting – more so,coz it’s a Revathy film!
August 31, 2004 — 11:19 pm
deelight says:
more so,coz it’s a Revathy film!
Yay to that!
September 1, 2004 — 2:03 am
Lakshmi says:
How was Fida? Shahid is a sweetie, isn’t he? I haven’t seen a single film of his yet, though…:-(
September 1, 2004 — 7:08 am
roopa1978 says:
He is so perfect for the role,coz he looks so innocent,and willing to do anything for the woman he loves. He looked fresh and young,while the other two looked old -infact both Kareena and Fardeen looked like they were on drugs.
September 1, 2004 — 9:25 pm
fugney says:
HIV was “not yet on the national radar screen the way it needs to be” in India, in part because the country hadn’t yet experienced what he termed “the ‘Philadelphia’ effect.”
Wasn’t Philadelphia more about homophobia?
September 1, 2004 — 4:20 am
Lakshmi says:
Haven’t seen the film…
September 1, 2004 — 7:09 am
fugney says:
WHHAAAT???!!! You must see it soon… it’s one of the best films I’ve ever seen.
September 2, 2004 — 1:13 am